27 Jul 2021

Tenacious Girls and Their Monsters

 I just finished Pan's Labyrinth and a slew of other fairytale esque movies/books and found I had quite a few thoughts on them. Especially regarding how different a heroine's story is compared to a hero's. 



It's a stark difference. For good reason, girls face things that are far removed from what a boy does. It's a completely separate path. One fraught with monsters, but not the ones you would expect, and unlike the hero the heroine doesn't always get to slay her dragons. 

She's usually not given a sword. 

She has to use different methods to win.

She has to trick them, outwit, and sometimes embrace them. But she rarely outright kills them. And I don't think she would if given the opportunity. Because the heroine unlike the hero tends to sympathize with the monster. She sometimes even sees a reflection of herself in it. Which leads to this fragile strange connection. 



It can lead to many things her saving and pitying the aforementioned beasts. She understands them in a way. Girlhood is not sweet and pink encrusted. It's sharp and bloody and full of perils. Like any good fairytale.

It's chocked full of metaphors.

 evil stepmothers/leering men/ riddles to solve/games to play/ the odds are always stacked against her/ she doesn't want to be what she is/ she fights everything and everyone even herself/she feels crazy, unwanted, and out of place/she hates her mother/she's scared to become her mother/she wishes she was a boy/ she hates boys/she might love boys /she wants to run away. 





So she does.


-She chases a rabbit into the woods and falls down a hole. 

-She finds wood in the back of a wardrobe. 

 -She finds herself separated from her parents in a strange place.

 -She gives up her life to a beast to save her father. 

 -She goes through a small door. 

 -She stumbles into a Labyrinth. 

 -She gets bought by a mage. 


The story gets retold a thousand ways. 


The world is never kind to these girls. Even the fantasy worlds try to trick and trap her. She has to prove her worth. She has to play the game. It's always a mirror of her, of her world. A series of lessons to help her comes to terms with whatever she has to face. 

She doesn't just grow she transforms. 

She has to come into her own. She has to bleed. She has to break. 

There's always a predator or adversary she has to face. Sometimes the true villain is in disguise. And the gruesome monster is a friend.



Sometimes she beats it, changes it, and sometimes she loves it.


 Which can end badly, a domesticated monster is still a monster after all.  

She gets called many things, witch, crazy, bitch, damsel. It's when she owns those words throws them back that she learns. A female is dangerous. Especially a young one. Untethered and wild. To be a girl is to be a ferocious thing. An enigma, hungry and unquenchable. 

And a girl is always underestimated. Because she's just a girl. A silly girl.

With the odds stacked against her, it's always that much more satisfying to see her win. 




She is given impossible tasks just as every girl is. To be beautiful but not vain. Innocent but seductive, sensible but never smart, to be feminine but unaffected. 

She tries even though she knows she'll fail. It's her spirit they can never break and it's always what saves her. 

Once she realizes she held the power all along the dynamic shifts. 

She takes control of herself and the narrative. Her adversary can no longer pill the strings. 


She wins her freedom, her power. Comes to term with her sexuality, womanhood, and sometimes even eventual motherhood. Uses the lessons, temptations, and pitfalls of the fantasy world and takes them back to the real world which is just as harsh and unfeeling towards her. 

But now she's ready to face it. She knows what to expect. She holds a secret in her teeth.

She will forever be that wild, tenacious girl. 

Nothing can break her. 

21 comments:

  1. I adore everything about this post. The descriptions, the points, the images, just everything. (some of the lines you wrote !! they're stunning)
    I love that heroine stories, particularly in this vein of story, are so primal. Sympathizing with monsters, taking down the real villain, being a bit monstrous ourselves, and realizing their/our own power. And the power dynamic shift moment fuels my will to live XD

    The love the ferociousness of it, the blood, the wildness, everything. And it's all so mixed up with loving things. Loving things itself is a kind of ferociousness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So glad you like it! (Thank you) :D
      Same, they super inspiring and layered. Yup all just part of the journey to adulthood.
      It's the best part.

      Yes, love is vicious.

      Delete
  2. OH MY. THIS IS SUCH GOOD STUFF!!! You know, I've never really thought of this before. But it's so true! Male protagonists tend to be on a quest to kill the monsters, while females quest to understand and overcome them. SUCH a fascinating thought.

    Also, this whole post was so lyrical and sharp and I want to quote like ALL of it. I love your posts so much! They always get me thinking and looking at things in a new way which is GREAT.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. AHH THANKS SO MUCH!!! I love that there's such a difference, might do a post on the hero's journey at some point too. But I definitely relate more to the heroine.

      That means a lot. Thanks again! I appreciate it. That's what I was hoping for with this one, glad it worked. <3

      Delete
  3. I can't even begin to explain how much I love this. You're such a talented writer.
    I think I'm going to need to look into watching Pan's Labyrinth now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad! Thank you, it was such a struggle to write.

      You should it's so good, brutal but good.

      Delete
  4. This post should be used as a reference on how to write strong female characters XD excellent analysis!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's such a nice compliment! Thank you so much!

      Delete
  5. This is such a fascinating understanding of deep female protagonists.

    And wow that Del Toro quote, so good. Kind of almost the fairytale version of the Bible verse "take heed lest you fall."

    I had to watch Pan's Labyrinth for a humanities class in college. I was rather more focused on avoided all the horror than focusing on the story.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, so glad you think so. :D

      He has so many good ones. Ooo yes, that fits.

      I was actually a bit scared to watch it, but I guess I've seen too many horror movies now for it to bother me.

      Delete
  6. This is a fascinating post.

    It explains a lot about why I've always felt so alienated from the traditional heroine's journey and so many classic heroines, because *whispers* I will always kill the monsters. Always. Every single freakin' time.

    I'm not saying that's better or worse: I'm saying that's who I am. And it GREATLY intrigues me to think about how that's such a different goal/mindset than the way the heroine's journey is usually presented, and how it influences the type of stories I write ... hmmmmmmm, yes, most fascinating, precioussssssssssssss ... *rubs hands*

    Thanks for giving me something cool to think about!!! :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you!

      That makes a lot of sense actually, it's so rare to find the type that does. Though depending on the monster, I'm with you on that.

      Love that, everyone is different. It effects how I write, so I find it super fascinating too. I'm always writing domestic monsters and trying to save them. It what makes your stories stand out to me. You have amazing female characters. This was the kind of reaction I was hoping for. <33

      Glad you found it interesting!! :D

      Delete
    2. Awwww! *blushes* Thanks, buddy!! It makes me happy that you love my female characters <3 I love yours too! *hugs for Snow especially*

      Delete
    3. Anytime!! I do their awesome! <3 I appreciate that so much!

      Delete
  7. YES. YES YES YES YES YES. I keep seeing these beautiful, vicious posts roll into my blog feed about the female power and the female worth. I'm captivated by this post it's quite literally art. Pass me a needle, I'm about to embroider the whole thing on a pillow. POETRY. Thank you for valuing our Gender and shedding light on what makes us special and DOESN'T have anything to do with our similarities to men.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. God, same.

      (hope you don't mind me jumping in)

      Delete
    2. Love this comment so much!! We need more beautiful, vicious posts. I'm always looking for ones like that. Ahh thank you so much! I felt like I rushed it, so I'm glad the points came across anyway. *flails* Thanks, I appreciate that.
      Yes, all about female worth here. I hate how tangled up with men everything tends to be, we need more stuff that's just for us.

      Delete
  8. I always love your posts, Skye <3

    ReplyDelete
  9. I... absolutely love this. So freaking beautiful.

    ReplyDelete